
   
    

	  	

  <../index.php>
  <200112>

------------------------------------------------------------------------
 -    	  	 
  2000 .    
<http://www.psychol.ru> 	  	 
------------------------------------------------------------------------
* #1-2 *  2001 . 	  	 


     : ,    ^*) <#*_>


    . 
    /  ,  ,  
        
    ,    
       <http://psychol.ru/>. /

        ...  
    -  ,
      
,      
....  ,    ....

 . ( )

        
  . ,    
  ,  ,  ,
 ,    (  ), 
 (, )  . , , 
,         , 
       ,    -
,      , 
 .     -  .

      ,   
    ,    ( )
" "     (   
),     ( )   
.   ,    
  ,      .   
    . -,    
,     .  
.  ,      - 
     :   -
    .  ,   -
   ,  
   .   ,   
      
       ,   
.       
    ,     
.

      
,     ,    
    ,      
.  ,    ,   
 ,     .   
  ,    . , 
/    
,        
,   . ,   ,
   ,     
     ,  .

    ,     
    .  , 
(  "" (splintering),    
,         
 ,   ) -   ,
  ,  -^1) <#1_>     
 (     ,    
),   ,    
  .   
    ,    
,       -,  
    ,     
.     ,     
   ,   ,  
   ,     
      ,  
  .      
,    . , ,
   ,    
     , 
   ,     
.

 ,    ,
     ,   
        ,
  ,      
.       
  ,    .


      

      
      - "",  
     .   
  ,    
    .       
  " "   
,      "insuffisance
psychologique", "absence", "etat seconde",  "double conscience". 
   .:

"         
  : ,      , 
,        
     ,  
         "
(vol. 2: 45).

,  , "" (alienation)    
 .  , ,  ,  
""      . ,  
 ,  "" ("Alienists").

       (  ,
       1909  
 1920 .)  ,     ,  
      .    
:

" -      , 
       .
 ,  ,     
     ,     
   ".

   , ,   ,   
,    .

"      ,  
    ,   
   .         
      ,      
 ;  ,    ,  , 
.." (Freud, 1909).

  :

"       
   ,     ,
     ;   
        
".

  / /    "absence",
"condition seconde"  "double conscience".    
    ,     
     ,   
     . 
     (, , , 
      -,   
  )     
    .

       
         
   ,     
,      .
   ,     "
",  ,      
 :

 , ,  ,   "  
,    ".  , 
     ,   
      ,      
 .

,  , "  -...
  ",    "
 -     
 ".

  - " " (` ,   
`),      
  ,   - , 
  " /( )/.

        
     (basic fault) (Balint, 1968),   
  "".    
,   ""    
  ,         
.   " ",    
,    ,   
" ".  " "    
 , ,    
 .

,         
 ,       , 
      "  "  ,
         
,        .   
  ,      ,  
 . "     ,  
   ,   ,   ,   
     ,     
, - ! -  . -      ,  
    ,        !"
( "  ",  . .  "  ", .,
1993).

      ,   
 ,     . 
: ",      ,   , 
    ,     , 
,  ,     ,  
 " ( ). , -,   ,
  -    
(Kilborne, 1995, 1999). ,  : "   -
   -      ,  
   .     ,  
 - , ,     -   
" ( ).


    ,   

  -   ,     
    .  
  ,    ,   , 
   .       
,  .     
         
,   , - ,    
    ,     
    ,    .

         ,
      , 
,      .  
    ,     
-       ,
(   (Levy & Inderbitzin, 1997),  
    , 
        , 
     .

 ,     
      .  
      
,  ,     
       .
        ,
   ,   ,  ",
,      
",    - " ,   
  ", " ,      
".  ,   ,  
  ,       
,     ("    ,
   ", -     ).  
  " ,    
,      
   " /( ) /. ,
      
       , 
     .

 ,     ,     ""
    ,   , 
      .  
    ,   
""    .


     ( 1)

       ,  
    ,   ,    
 -    .  
  .       ,
     .     
   ,   ,  ,
  ,    , ,
   .      
,         ,  
 , ,   ,     
     .        
    , .      
  .       
     ,      
  .

        
,       ,    ,
      ,      
 . "  ", -     ,  
,  "    ";   " ".

        ,  
       .  
   ,    , 
  ,         
.         
  ,     . 
    ,     ,
  ,      .
    ,  
,   ,   ,    
  ,       
   -  .

         , 
     ,    
 ,     ,   
      ,    
     .      
          
,   ,  ,    
,     .  ,   
,     .       
,         .
       ( , ,
  , ,  ),    
    , 
    ,      
 ,  -,    .

,   ,     , , 
,      ,    
   , , ,  - 
            ,
  .

      ,  , 
,     (holding environment).
       ,   
   .       , 
  ,  ,     .  
     
 .  -  ,   
""  ,    ,    
  .        (
 )      . 
          .

        ,  
 ,          
      ,    . "
    ", -  ,  , 
 .     ,    
      ,   
,         
 ,        - 
  ,    .  
     -      
.     ,     .

       
 ,   ,    
 .        
 ,      
       .  
   ,     
   .      ,  
    ,     
 .       ,  ,
     .

     ,  
      
,        
        
  . ,   ,  
     ,    
      .


    ,   

       ,     
     (.   
",   "  " ").  
    .     
   , ,    
.          
,        .  
  ,     "   
   " /( )/.  ,
        
 (   ,    
),    ,     
,   -    ,    
  ,       .


     ( 2)

 ,      ,  ,  
,  ,   ,     .
,         
-   ,    
: ,     
 ,   -.    
       ,  
        
  (, Hanal, 1987, 1989, 1991; Hoffer,
1991; Fogel, 1993; Kirschner, 1993; Kilborne, 1999).  , , 
,       , 
         
  .       
  ,      
,     (Winnicott, 1949).

  ,      ,  ,  
            
 ,       .    
     ,   ,
      .    
  ,         
    .    ,   
,  ,     , 
 ,          
 .   ,  
,       . 
   ,   
/ .      
,   (, ),     ,
    .      ,
     ,      
     .     .
     ,  
   (   ).

         
  -   .   
 -, ,   ,   ,   
   .     ,   
          ,  - 
,    ,  : "    ,
     .        . 
    ,  ".    ,
    ,     , 
   ,       .  
    ,    . 
  ,        - , 
  ,      .  
   ,   ,
    ,   
   .    
" ",     " " 
 "  ".     
       .   
   -     . 
   ,   .  ,   
,    ,    
   ,        
  .     ,  
 ,  ,     ,
  .

 ,         
   ,   ,
 ,     - .  ,
  ,      
 . ,     ,
      ,    
.  ,       
 .      ,     
    ,   
;      ,      
?        
.  ,      
,       , 
   ,     
 (, , ,   .),   
   .       
   ,   ,    
 ,  ,       
 .

        , , 
 , ,     ,
   ,    
  ..        , 
       
,   .   
 ,  "    " /
( ) /.  :

   ,      
       
(  )   ,    
   ,     ,  
  .   ,  
  ,   ". / (
) /.

    ,       
,     -,    
.     
        
.     ,   
 "" ,     
 ,       
-   .    
  ,    
 ,    ,  
 ,      ,
     .

, ,       
        , 
       
,       
,        
,    . ,  
,      (
  ),  /    
     () 
( - ,   ,    
 ).        
 ,      
.       
 ,    ,  
       
        
   (. Wurmser, Morrison, Malin, Reed, &
Lichtenberg,     ,
1999).

  , ,  ,   
,     . , 
      ,   
,      (1968).  
     .   ,
    ,   ,
"      " /( )
/.       .
"        
,       
   " /( ) /  
   ,   
.        ,
   ,  ,  
    ,    
.      
  ,     
 ,      
.

   ,      
      .  ,
   ,    ,  .  
   .    - ,   
, -   ,       , 
    ,    .  
  ,       - " 
", "", ""   .    
  ,   ,    ,   
,    ,       ,  
    -  ,   // ,  
 ,    //         
 ,    .      
          , 
    ,     
,      .  
       (  
,   ).

 ,      
 ,      (  
     ),   
.       
,    ,   
 ,      ;  
 ,   -      ,
     ,     
,     ,   
 .    ,  
  (      ) 
   .    
        
         .   
    - ,  , 
     .

  -       
   . "  
     ,  ,   "
/( ) /      
 ,        
 .      
  "   ",  
  .

    ,   ,  
     :    
     .       ,
    ,   ,    ,  
 ;       ,    
,         ,
  ()  .   ,
     , ,   ,
    . ",    ,
  , -  ,   ,   
  ,       
" (Loevald, 1951).      .
      ,  
  // (Loevald, 1987; Lear, 1996).


         

     ,   
   ,     .
,      
  ,     
,       
 .  :

"    ,  
      ,   
 .   ,     
-  ,       
,     ,    
.    ,     
     ,    
        
,     -    ,
 ,     " /(
) /

 " "    ,  
"  "        "
  " (1936). ,   1931   1932  
  "  " (Ferenczi, 1931, 1932).
 ,         
" ",      . 
      
  ,   ,   
         .

  ,     
,       ( )
     .    
        
  ( )        
          
         
(. Kilborne, 1999).

 "  "     , 
    ,   
   ,      
          
.     
       , 
   .     
 .   :

      ,     .  
,     ,   
   .   
,      
.    , ,   
       ,   
    ,   
 /( ) /

,   -     ,
     . " 
        ,   
     ,    "
/( ) /        
,   ,      
,     .   
    ,   
     .  
        
     ,
          
 ,     (. Winnicott, 1949). 
       
          
 .


    ,    

    ,   ,
        ,  
    .    
   ,    ,
     .  , 
  ,   ,  
,       
 "".    ,    
   -  ,   , 
     , -   
?        
?  -     , ,  
,     (.,
, Ferenczi, 1926,  Balint, 1968).

      ,  
  ,    ,   .  
  "    "
(1919)  : "      , 
   ,   ,   , 
     ,   
 ".    -   
  ,   
     .  ,   
   ,       
 ,    ,    
. ,   ,  ,   
  :  ,      
         .

       
      , 
   ,    //,  ,
     ...      
 ,  ,    ,
   (Freud, .  Ferenczi, 1926).

,   :   ,  ,
"  ,       ".  
,  , "   ". 
        , 
         
 .      
 , " ,      
     ,   , 
 ,    " /( ) /

  ,       
  -  ,     
.     -     
-        
( , ,   ).  , 
  ,  ,    
,       
   ,    ""  ""
"   -     - 
  ,    
" (Fogel, 1993).

       
 ,    .   
 ,    ,   , 
  .  ,        
 , " ",   
,    "-",   
"--", ,    (.,
, Brenner, 1996; Krystal, 1978).  :

  ,       
  , ,  ,   
   (  ),
   ,   , 
     ,    
 ,      .
  ,      
       
.        ,    
 /( ) /

    ,     
 :      
 ,      . 
 ,       
         
 .        
   , ,  
,   .  ,    
     ""    
  "",   //    
     .


    

  ,       
       . 
          
 ,       
 .  , ,  
       
,    .   , 
 ,      ,   
  ,     ,   
  ,      , 
    -   -    
      .

       
       
       
    . ,    ,  
     ,   
    ,     .
,        
       
  ,        
 .

. . , . 


    

American Psychoanalytic Association (1999). Panel "Shame Contempt
Interchanges." Washington, D.C., meeting.

Balint, Michael (1968). The Basic Fault: Therapeutic Aspects of
Regression. London: Tavistock Publications.

Bonomi, Carlo (1998). Flight into sanity: Jones' allegation of
Ferenczi's mental deterioration reconsidered. Unpublished manuscript.

Brener, Ira (1996). Trauma, perversion and "multiple personality." I.
Am. Psychoanal. Assoc. 44 (3): 785-814.

Ferenczi, Sandor (1909). Introjection and transference. In Clara
Thompson (ed.), Selected Papers of Sandor Ferenczi, vol. 1. New York:
Basic Books, 1950.

Ferenczi, Sandor (1914). Embarassed hands. In John Rickman (ed.). The
Selected Papers of Sandor Ferenzci, vol. 2. New York: Basic Books, 1960.

Ferenczi, Sandor (1926). The Problem of acceptance of unpleasant
ideas-advances in knowledge of the sense of reality. In John Rickman
(ed.). The Selected Paper'; of Sandor Ferenczi, vol. 2. New York: Basic
Books, 1960.

Ferenczi, Sandor (1931). Notes and fragments, aphoristic remarks on the
theme of being dead-being a woman. In M. Balint (ed.), Final
Contributions to the Problems and Methods of Psychoanalysis. London:
Karnac Books, 1994.

Ferenczi, Sandor (1932). The Clinical Diary of Sandor Ferenczi, Judith
Dupont (ed.), Michael Balint and Nicola Zarday Jackson, trans.
Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1988.

Ferenczi, Sandor (1933). The Confusion of tongues. In M. Balint (ed.),
Selected Paper'; of Sandor Ferenczi, vol. 3. New York: Basic Books, 1955.

Fogel, Gerald (1993). A transitional phase in our understanding of the
psychoana lytic process a new look at Ferenczi and Rank I Am Psychoanal
Assoc 2 585-602

Freud, Ana [1936 (1966)] The Ego and the Mechanisms of Defense London
Hogarth Press Ltd

Freud, Sigmund (1895) (with J Breuer) Studies on hysteria Standard
Edition 2 45ff

Freud, Sigmund (1909) Lectures on psychoanalysis Standard Edition 9 252ff

Freud, Sigmund (1914) Remembering, repeating and working through
Standard Edition 1 2 147ff

Freud, Sigmund (1919) A child is being beaten Standard Edition 17 179ff

Freud, Sigmund (1919) Lines of advance in psychoanalytic therapy
Standard Edition 12

Haynal, Andre (1987) The Technique at Issue Controversies in
Psychoanalysis from Freud and Ferenczi to Michael Balint London Karnac

Haynal, Andre (1989) The concept of trauma and its present meaning Int
Rev Psycho anal 16 315-321

Haynal, Andre (1991) The psychoanalytic movement healing through love1'
A unique dialogue in the history of psychoanalyse Free Associations 21 1 -20

Hotter, Axel (1991) The Freud-Ferenczi controversy-a living legacy Int
Rev Psy-choanal 18 465-472

Hotter, Axel (1998) (with Peter Hotter) Ferenczi's fatal illness in
historical context Paper presented at American Psychoanalytic
Association meetings, Toronto

Kierkegaard, Soren (1849) The Sickness Unto Death. Alastair Hannay,
trans London and New York Penguin, 1989

Kilborne, Benjamin (1995) Of creatures large and small, psychic size,
size anxiety and the analytic situation The Psychoanalytic Quarterly 64
672-690

Kilborne, Benjamin (1999a) The disappearing who Kierkegaard, shame and
the self In J Adamson and H Clark (eds), Scenes of Shame Psychoanalysis,
Shame and Writing Albany State University of New York Press

Kilborne, Benjamin (1999b) Ferenczi, regression and shame. Int Annals
Pscyho-analysis, in press

Kirschner, Lewis (1993) Concepts of reality and psychic reality in
psychoanalysis as illustrated by the disagreement between Freud and
Ferenczi Int j Psycho-anal 75 219-230

Krystal, Henry (1978) Trauma and affects Psychoanal Study Child 33 81-116

Lansky, Melvin (1992) Fathers Who Fail Hillsdale, N) The Analytic Press

Lear, Jonathan (1996) The Introduction of eros j Am Psychoanal Assoc 44
(3) 696

Levy Steven T, and Inderbitzin, Lawrence  (1997) Safety and danger and
the analyst's authority j Am Psychoanal Assoc 45 (2) 377-394

Loewald, Hans (1951) Ego and reality Int J Psychoanal 32 10-18

Loewald Hans (1987) Some considerations on repetition and the repetition
compulsion In Papers on Psychoanalysis New Haven Yale University Press

'Martin Cabre, Luis) (1997) Freud-Ferenczi controversy terminable and
interminable Int J Psycho Anal 78 105-114

Winnicott, D W (1949) Hate in the countertransference Int j Psycho-Anal
30 69-74

Wurmser, Leon (1981) The Mask of Shame Baltimore Johns Hopkins
University Press


    

^*) <#*>   : When trauma strikes the soul: shame,
splitting and pain. The American Journal of Psychoanalysis, vol. 59, No.
4. 1999

^1) <#1>  -  ,   3 . ,
,  ,   ,  , . 
         ,
        . - . .

    <20011214>

| [5358[6483]] |
------------------------------------------------------------------------
()     , 2001 .
  .     
 .

@Mail.ru <http://top.mail.ru/jump?from=48868>
